Kaltro raises a lift’s target weight only after a clear gate closes: every working set in your last session reached the top of its rep range, you have repeated that top for the required number of sessions, and your recent effort was not too high. Until all three hold, it keeps the weight and builds reps instead. Even once they do, two things can still stop a weight increase: the smallest step your equipment allows would be too big a jump, or the next step would be heavier than the heaviest load you have told Kaltro you own for that kind of equipment. Either way it builds reps, sets or a harder variation instead. Only at the very top of that ladder can Kaltro still suggest a step that is too big, with the reps reset — never one past the heaviest load you have told it you own. The climb back after a shorter break, described below, works to targets of its own.

What follows is the exact order the engine works through, from the shipping suggestion engine. These constants are design choices — informed by training research, chosen by us, and tunable — not claims that any single number is optimal.

The order Kaltro checks things

A weight increase is the last thing the engine considers, not the first. It walks a fixed decision tree and stops at the first rule that applies.

  1. Only resistance training gets a weight increase. Cardio is skipped; stretching and mobility work never gets more load — timed holds progress by duration instead.
  2. Only the first working set of a lift drives the suggestion; later sets carry that decision forward so the whole exercise stays consistent.
  3. It reads your recent history — the trailing 90 days, counting only completed working sets (warm-ups and drop sets never count).
  4. Flagged injuries lock progression on that lift until you clear them.
  5. Enough evidence first: no progression until it has seen the lift enough times — see how much history Kaltro needs.
  6. Deloads pre-empt everything: if a deload trigger fires, the weight comes down and the increase logic never runs.
  7. After a shorter break, the climb back comes next: Kaltro steps back toward the weight you held before the break, one capped step at a time. Each step has its own rep target in place of the top-of-range rule, the effort ceiling still applies, and the consistency count is set aside until the climb ends — see time away on the deload page.
  8. Then double progression: the rep and effort gates below.
  9. Finally, the size of the jump — the smallest loadable step, capped (the largest one inside that cap on the climb back after a break) — and whether that step stays within the heaviest load you have told Kaltro you own for that equipment.

Double progression: reps before weight

Kaltro uses double progression — you earn reps at a weight before the weight goes up. The idea is widely used; the specific rule that every working set must reach the top of the range before an increase is ours.

  • Every working set has to hit the top of its rep range last session — not just your best set. One set short and Kaltro holds the weight and asks for every working set to reach the top next time — it adds no weight and prescribes no extra reps. After a break, each step back asks for something different: every working set at that weight reaching the reps your log shows you held before the break (never fewer than the bottom of the range), with logged effort at or under its usual ceiling — not the top of the range.
  • Rep ranges depend on the movement: compound lifts use 8–12, isolation work 12–15, adjusted for your goal; power and olympic lifts use a lower power range; isolation never drops below 8.
  • Beginners get 2 extra reps of runway above the top before an increase is offered — a deliberately gentler ramp while form settles. This applies to ranges Kaltro picked. When a template states its own rep range, we treat that as the author’s decision and use their top as written — unless the safety limits above replace it, in which case the range is ours again and so is the runway.

Read the plain-English version in the glossary: what double progression means.

The consistency gate

Hitting the top once is not enough. Kaltro waits until you have repeated the top of the range at roughly the same weight, session after session.

  • Repeat the top at the same weight (within about 2.5%) for a set number of consecutive sessions before the weight moves. Coming back from a break is the exception: one session that meets a step’s target moves you to the next step, and only the last step back asks for two sessions in a row.
  • How many depends on experience: typically 1 session for beginners, 2 for intermediate lifters, 3 for advanced. While you climb back after a break this count is set aside. Once the climb ends, it applies as usual to any weight still below the one you held before the break; only the first increase past that weight counts just the sessions since the break. If the climb stopped at the heaviest load you have told Kaltro you own, below the weight you held before, meeting the count leads to more reps, more sets or a harder variation, not more weight. Kaltro shows a “confirmed 1 of 2”-style note while it counts. We say “typically” because your nutrition phase, an injury you are ramping back from, and how your own recent sessions have gone can all move that count. When your e1RM trend has flattened, or at least half your recent weight jumps did not hold, Kaltro can ask for one more confirming session before the weight moves — one more, never more than one. The other direction is narrower: it only ever removes a session where three were required, so an advanced lifter whose jumps keep holding can be asked for 2 sessions instead of 3.

The effort ceiling

If last session felt very hard, Kaltro holds the weight even when the rep gate is met. This is a fatigue-management guard, not a claim about the best effort for muscle growth.

  • When your logged RPE averaged above your effort ceiling last session, the weight holds. That ceiling is RPE 8 for most lifters — research on proximity to failure supports treating an 8 as a sensible fatigue boundary rather than an intensity target (Robinson et al., 2024). High effort plus more load is how good sessions turn into stalls, so Kaltro waits for the effort to settle.
  • RPE is optional. If you do not log it, nothing is assumed and this gate simply does not apply — Kaltro never invents an effort score.
  • An early bump can happen: if last session’s sets at your heaviest working weight were genuinely easy — RPE 6 or lower, logged on at least three-quarters of those sets — Kaltro can raise the weight before you reach the top of the range. It also has to be a weighted lift, with your reps at or above the range bottom, and at least your second session at that same top weight (sessions at other weights in between are simply skipped). The signal is research-backed (Zourdos et al., 2016); the exact thresholds are ours. That 6 is the standard bar, and for most lifters it stays the only one: it can rise as high as 6.5, but only once your recent jumps have kept holding and at least two of those top-weight sets carry a logged effort score — never within a full point of your effort ceiling, so a lower ceiling lowers this too. Beginners, anyone returning after a long break, and anyone in a calorie deficit keep the 6. An early bump never takes you past the heaviest load you have told Kaltro you own for that equipment: if the next step would, the bump is dropped and the normal gates run as if it had not fired.

How big the jump is

Once the gates clear, Kaltro picks the smallest increase your equipment actually allows, caps its size, and stops short of any load you have told it you do not own. On the climb back after a break, it takes the largest step inside that same cap instead.

  • One loadable step, rounded to the plates or fixed increments you can really load. On the way back from a break, a step can be larger — the biggest loadable jump inside the same cap — and never goes past the weight you held before the break, or past the heaviest load you have told Kaltro you own.
  • Capped at 10% for compound lifts and 15% for isolation — 10% for both if you are newer or returning. The narrower isolation cap applies when the training age in your profile is under three years, is a return after a long break, or is not set — a deliberately smaller step while connective tissue catches up. If the smallest possible step is still larger than the cap, Kaltro does not suggest it straight away. A step heavier than the heaviest load you have told Kaltro you own for that kind of equipment is never suggested (see below).
  • Instead it climbs a ladder: add reps first (up to three past the top of the range); then, once your first working set reaches that rep limit, either a harder variation or an extra set, in the order below; then, once an exercise is at its set limit (5 working sets at most), the harder variation again. Kaltro never prescribes a weight on the new exercise — you start it fresh.
  • The harder variation comes before an extra set when it is ready: Kaltro has one listed for the lift that you can do with the equipment you have told it you own (if you have not said, it takes the first one listed); it has seen the lift at least 4 times; and your first working set reached the rep limit in each of your last two sessions at that weight. If any of that is missing — no variation listed, equipment you do not have, only one good session — it moves on to adding a set instead. The variation is an offer, never an automatic swap. Turn it down once and, from your next workout, Kaltro offers sets instead, up to 5 working sets, where the variation is offered again. A lift you have flagged as injured, or are ramping back on, is never moved to a harder variation.
  • At the very top of the ladder, the weight can still go up one step, with the reps reset. When your first working set reaches the rep limit, you are at the set limit, and there is no harder variation you can do with your equipment, Kaltro suggests the one step your equipment allows, even though it is over the cap, with your reps starting at the bottom of the range. It does this only when an estimate from your last session’s reps, rounded down, says you can reach that range bottom at the new weight (otherwise it holds); when it has seen the lift at least 4 times; when the step is no more than 20% heavier than what you lifted — 15% for a lift the narrower isolation cap above applies to; and only for ranges whose bottom is 3 reps or more. Never in a calorie deficit, never on a lift you have flagged as injured, never on a power or olympic lift, and never past the heaviest load you have told Kaltro you own. Your rep target is never at or above what you did last session.
  • After an increase, targets reset low: reps drop back toward the bottom of the range, and are never set at or above what you did last session — you re-earn the reps at the new weight. On a step back after a break, the target is instead the reps you held before the break, which can match last session’s.

The heaviest your equipment goes

If the next step up is a load you do not own, Kaltro stops suggesting it — but only once you have said so. It never guesses what you have.

  • You can tell Kaltro the heaviest load you own for a kind of equipment: the most you can put on a bar, bar included; the heaviest single dumbbell (one bell, not the pair); the heaviest kettlebell; or the most you can hang from a dip belt or vest. Barbell, dumbbell and kettlebell limits live in your profile under Your Equipment, beside the equipment you have said you own. You can set any of them, a belt or vest load included, from the reasoning shown with a suggestion, and Kaltro may ask once for a lift where it has suggested more weight several sessions running and you kept the same top weight each time. No answer means no limit is assumed. Machine weight stacks are not covered.
  • A limit only ever stops an increase. When the next loadable step would go past it, Kaltro skips the weight increase and climbs the same ladder — reps, then a harder variation or a set — and its note names your equipment as the reason. It never lowers a weight because of a limit.
  • Lift heavier and the limit stands down. If a working set on that lift in your recent history, from a workout after you gave the number, goes above it — new bells, a typo — Kaltro treats the limit as out of date for that lift and stops applying it there until you update it. Heavier sets from workouts before that do not count — they are usually from before the change that made you set one.

This page describes how the engine reaches each decision. Which suggestions the app displays in full can depend on your plan — see pricing. The reasoning above is the same regardless of tier.

See the reasoning behind every suggestion

Log a workout and Kaltro runs exactly these rules, then shows you why it suggested what it did — from the sets you logged, on your device.

Keep reading: when Kaltro calls a deload, how much history it needs first, and how it reads your e1RM trend. Terms in plain English: double progression and RPE. To see all four outcomes in the app, read how Kaltro works.

The research behind this

  • Robinson et al. (2024). Sports Medicine.
  • Zourdos et al. (2016). Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research.